Joni Mitchell: The Eternal Music of a Demi-Saint

Web Editor

September 28, 2025

a typewriter with a face drawn on it and a caption for the words opinion and a question, Edward Otho

Introduction

Music has a unique way of creating lasting memories. Rainy afternoons evoke the football fields where I spent my childhood, while my brothers trained for heroics. Meanwhile, I played in the mud until the rain fell, cherishing the scent of grass and earth that symbolizes my youth.

Radio 6.20: A Nostalgic Gateway

Schooldays bring forth another memory. Early mornings, traffic, the rush to school, and cold air laden with smog. All these woes were soothed by the radio music, specifically Radio 6.20, “the music that came to stay.”

My father always defaulted to 6.20, as it played the music from his youth: Dave Clark Five, Donovan, The Ronettes, Diana Ross, Box Tops, Ray Charles, and The Hollies. My father never favored The Beatles; he committed the cardinal sin of preferring The Monkees. Radio 6.20 was his portal to simpler times, devoid of traffic and more straightforward living: school and then billiards.

Discovering Joni Mitchell

While doing homework in the backseat, I was captivated by this music. My favorite program was El Hit Parade, a list of songs that had topped the charts in the distant past—the 1950s, ’60s, and ’70s. The announcer presented each song with the year and its ranking on U.S. popularity charts.

Through El Hit Parade, I discovered Joni Mitchell. Her hit “Big Yellow Taxi” from 1971 caught my attention, though I didn’t understand the lyrics. The song’s infectious laughter made me smile, as if it came from someone who knew the absurdity of life: sing, laugh, and make a fortune through art.

Joni Mitchell’s Unique Voice

I adore Joni Mitchell, not just for her exceptional songwriting and musical composition skills but also for her distinct voice. It’s as if she hails from another planet, speaking directly to me. Unlike Janis Joplin’s powerful, gut-wrenching voice or Judee Sill’s whispered tones, Mitchell’s voice is unique. It reminds me of my mother singing a bolero.

Canadian Icon

I knew little about Joni until high school, when I learned she was Canadian, not Angelina as her Ladies of the Canyon suggested. I pictured her emerging from Los Angeles canyons during a cultural revolution. However, her wild state originates from the Canadian plains, its cold and solitude shaping her artistry.

As a teenager, I burned CDs of music I couldn’t afford to buy originally. Thanks to Napster, I acquired several Joni Mitchell albums. Bless piracy.

Revisiting Joni’s Discography

My favorite albums were Blue and Mingus, but recently I rediscovered Clouds (1969) due to “Both Sides Now,” a favorite among her songs. Critics often reference “A Case of You” when discussing Joni, but I found solace in this underrated track through John Carney’s Flora and Son. The protagonist hears it faintly, then fully comprehends its meaning as it breaks down her Irish-hard barriers.

The song’s poetic truth, disguised as pop music, encapsulates a philosophical realization: life’s secrets are exhausted when you realize your ignorance in a pivotal moment. Joni Mitchell, with her guitar, channels Nietzsche.

Joni Mitchell: A Complex Personality

Mitchell’s songs are brilliant, but her personality surpasses them. During the pandemic, I developed a fondness for public figures’ memoirs and biographies. David Yaffe’s Reckless Daughter became a favorite, offering an intricate portrait of Joni.

Yaffe recounts his experience interviewing Mitchell for The New York Times, describing himself as a nervous, aspiring reporter. He brings Nietzsche books and Rudyard Kipling’s “If,” both influential in Mitchell’s songs. They meet at an Italian restaurant, where Joni smokes extensively. The interview extends to a 24-hour conversation at her home, continuing via calls and emails.

Though Mitchell dislikes the interview, claiming her home was unfairly labeled “middle-class,” Yaffe, a longtime admirer, now understands journalism transcends fandom.

Joni Mitchell’s Enduring Legacy

Joni Mitchell is as crucial to pop music as Elvis or Bob Dylan. Her mystique extends beyond eras and trends. Though she retired after a 2015 aneurysm, her music remains timeless, never fading away. It’s truly the music that came to stay.

Key Questions and Answers

  • Who is Joni Mitchell? A Canadian singer-songwriter, considered one of the most influential musicians in pop music history.
  • Why is Joni Mitchell significant? Her unique voice, exceptional songwriting, and enduring music have solidified her place among musical legends like Elvis Presley and Bob Dylan.
  • What is the significance of “Both Sides Now”? A poignant song that encapsulates a philosophical realization about life’s secrets and ignorance.
  • What is David Yaffe’s Reckless Daughter? A biography offering an intricate portrait of Joni Mitchell, exploring her life, relationships, and artistic evolution.
  • Why did Joni Mitchell dislike David Yaffe’s interview? She took issue with her home being described as “middle-class,” believing it to be a misrepresentation.