Apple Challenges Italian Antitrust Fine for Abuse of Dominant Position

Web Editor

December 23, 2025

two people holding up two new iphones in their hands, one blue and one green, in front of a white ba

Background on Apple and the Italian Antitrust Decision

Apple Inc., the American technology giant, has expressed its “total disagreement” with a decision by Italy’s antitrust authority imposing a €98.6 million fine for allegedly abusing its dominant market position. The fine stems from Apple’s App Tracking Transparency (ATT) policy, which was implemented in April 2021 to enforce stricter privacy rules on developers offering apps through the App Store.

Who is Apple?

Apple Inc. is a multinational technology company headquartered in Cupertino, California. Known for its innovative consumer electronics, software, and online services, Apple has become a dominant player in the smartphone, tablet, and personal computer markets. Its products include the iPhone, iPad, Mac computers, Apple Watch, and the App Store, which hosts millions of apps developed by independent developers.

Why is this relevant?

Apple’s dominant position in the digital marketplace makes its decisions and policies significant for both users and competitors. The ATT policy, in particular, has sparked debates about privacy, data protection, and the balance of power between tech giants and smaller developers.

The Italian Antitrust Decision

In collaboration with the European Commission, Italy’s antitrust authority, the Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato (AGCM), decided to fine Apple €98.6 million for restricting competition through its ATT policy.

What is the App Tracking Transparency (ATT) policy?

The ATT policy requires developers to clearly explain the data they collect from users and obtain explicit permission before tracking their activity across other companies’ apps and websites. This policy aims to enhance user privacy by giving them more control over their personal data.

Apple’s Response

In a statement, Apple expressed its “total disagreement” with the decision, arguing that the ATT policy offers substantial privacy protections for users and benefits technology companies focused on advertising as well as data-tracking businesses.

Apple’s stance on privacy

Apple emphasizes its commitment to user privacy, viewing it as a fundamental human right. The company believes that the ATT policy provides users with an easy way to control their data and ensures equal application of privacy rules to all developers, including Apple itself.

Key Questions and Answers

  • What is the fine about? The Italian antitrust authority fined Apple €98.6 million for allegedly abusing its dominant market position through the App Tracking Transparency (ATT) policy.
  • What is the App Tracking Transparency (ATT) policy? The ATT policy requires developers to obtain explicit user consent before tracking their activity across other companies’ apps and websites, aiming to enhance user privacy.
  • Why is Apple disputing the fine? Apple argues that the ATT policy offers significant privacy protections for users and benefits various technology companies, including those focused on advertising and data tracking.
  • What is Apple’s stance on privacy? Apple views privacy as a fundamental human right and believes that the ATT policy provides users with control over their personal data while applying equal privacy rules to all developers.